Okay...changing the idea around a little bit for this story.
The Elemental Coven will be formed of:
Athena convinces Depraved Angel, Sinful_stiches and Yummyteece to leave the coven to form the Dark Guild where the will conduct the ultimate summoning of power so that they may rule the world.
Holy Dragon gathers those who are left and tells them they must recast the elements so that they may band together and summon the elemental_fey
as the Earth's protector against the Dark Guild's evil. But where are they to get replacements for Darkness, Air, Fire and Water?
, a phasing cat burglar, happens to try and steal from the wrong place and interrupts the ritual the Dark Guild was conducting to summon their power. The ritual goes wrong as their powers are corrupted. Athena and Sinful Stiches are disfigured with batwings and horns, Yummyteece loses her eye, and Depraved Angel is taken over by the malignant spirit of a Fallen One.
Athena detects the unlucky Phantom, and sends out demonic creatures into the night to capture her. Sinful Stitches, however, does not tell the others that the changes to her form have caused her to have a change of heart. She goes out to search for Phantom, but to save her from the creatures. They have battles with the creatures and end up making their way back to the Elemental Coven where Phantom informs them of what she saw and Sinful Stitches begs for forgiveness and acceptance back in the Coven.
Holy Dragon informs Stitches that her powers have changed, however...and she can no longer be the Water Mage. But perhaps she could be the new Dark Mage? Phantom is also informed by Holy Dragon that she posesses innate abilities with air that giver her her phasing powers...perhaps she could be the new Air Mage?
Blairwitch Green and Agraywitch go out to search for a roaming man rumored to have the powers over water...as in i_am_stillwater
Unfortunately for them, Depraved Angel has something to say about that...
Graywitch has the abilities of balance...could he summon the powers of fire to complete the circle?
Various battles occur, people get trained, etc. and the new coven will manage to summon Elemental Fey to the final battle of Darkness vs. Light.
(*side note: minerva_fan
will be saved by Elemental Fey during one of the battles and later become Fey's girlfriend)